Yeah, we should have this back, but if possible then it should be such that no one, not even the admins, are able to figure out who said what.
And as an additional idea... maybe for this time round, we don't just say our secrets, but that like the actual Post Secret, we get a little bit creative. Like, maybe not go to the effort of doing a photoshop if we don't feel like it, but at least throw in a graphic or two, use different fonts, etc. It would keep things interesting.